T on the Fringe 2005
Friday 5th to Wednesday 31st August 2005various venues, Edinburgh city centre, Scotland, Scotland MAP
£5 to £30, dependant on event
Pixies / Idlewild / Teenage Fanclub / My Latest Novel @ Meadowbank Stadium, 28/08/05
Scottish group My Latest Novel failed to get anything out of the crowd at this gig. The stadium was half empty for them, and only latest single Sister Sneaker Sister Soul suggested that they have any chance whatsoever to rise above the position of opener on these type of shows.
Its pretty, sure, but just because something is pretty doesnt mean it cant be deathly dull. In fact, My Latest Novel would do well to take a leaf out of Teenage Fanclubs notebook. The Scottish favourites played a set of fragile yet engaging rock, with older songs taking place alongside new material such as Fallen Leaves.
Teenage Fanclub manage to get a bit more out of the crowd, but despite having worked with Pixies frontman Frank Black in the past, they dont seem the right band for the support slot.
Trust Idlewild then, to save the day. Opening with Little Discourage and You Held The World In Your Arms, their unique brand of grunge-tinged rock managed to get a good reaction.
A set full of great songs proved to be a hit, and despite a surprising omission of American English, singles such as Love Steals Us From Lonliness, Live In A Hiding Place, I Understand It and closing trio When I Argue I See Shapes, El Capitan and A Film For The Future, they prove to be a great warm up to the main event.
Its incredible that after such a good support slot, that Pixies can blow every other band on the bill into oblivion. Having regrown some of his hair and wearing a suit, Frank Black and the band launch straight into an incredible opening quartet of Bone Machine, Stormy Weather, Jesus & Mary Chain cover Head On and U-Mass.
The crowd is unbelievable for the influential 80s punk band, singing along to every word, and Monkey Gone To Heaven is the first sing-a-long of the day.
Pixies are incredibly animated for the gig, and give a good amount of banter. Where their T in the Park gig last year was slightly stand-offish, the band seem relaxed and as if they are enjoying themselves.
Rarer number such as Neil Young cover Winterlong, Blown Away, Into the White and Ed is Dead get a look-in tonight, but the surprise smash of the night is not Debaser, Where Is My Mind or even Gouge Away, but the deliberately cheesy La La Love You, which Frank Black dedicates to all the lovely ladies.
Closing with Vamos, Where Is My Mind, and an encore of Gigantic, this band may have been arguably the best reformed band last year, now have an argument that they are the best band around today period. Its a bold claim, but in the basis of tonight, not all that far-fetched.
review by Matthew Shaw
Latest Updates
The Edge Festival (formerly T on the Fringe)
festival home page
festival home page
last updated: Mon 1st Feb 2016
Edge Festival 2011
festival details
festival details
last updated: Thu 9th Jun 2011
Edge Festival 2011
line-ups & rumours
line-ups & rumours
last updated: Thu 9th Jun 2011
first acts announced for Edge Festival
The National, Jimmy Eat World, Example, Wiz Khalifa, Gomez, & more
The National, Jimmy Eat World, Example, Wiz Khalifa, Gomez, & more
last updated: Thu 9th Jun 2011
Edge Festival 2010
line-ups & rumours
line-ups & rumours
last updated: Fri 20th Aug 2010