Neil Young Vs Bruce Springsteen

[Jens Wildman]

not really sure what you mean.. 'the look on his face'?

but never mind, we seem to agree that it was more than likely live... if it wasn't why they didn't they re-do the dodgy backing vocals in Working On A Dream? (the ooh la la la bit)

Edited February 5, 2009 by Jens Wildman

[SJ121]

The Boss would kick Neil's ass in a fist fight.

However if it came to a sword fight with Guitars then Neil would have the upper hand, waving his Gibson like a broadsword. But one slip up and the boss would finish him with a thrusting telecaster to the chest.

Musically though I don't have a view......

[alframsey]

I do love them, not in the biblical sense, but their music. Suppose a lot of their songs just hit the spot with me. Pretty similar to a lot of Pink Floyd stuff.

[Red Day]

Now Pink Floyd. I am fanatical about them!!! I love them and all their stuff. I have every album 3 times over on CD, most twice on vinyl and some box sets! And som collector vinyls, etc. I really am fanatical!!! I am devastated they will not play together again!

[alframsey]

Know that feeling there's just something about their music that hits every spot

[strudders]

Honestly, who needs drugs when you have PF??? The best band ever!!!

[Ashaz42]

I'd have to go with the Boss hands down. I saw him in Cardiff (with the E Street Band) last summer and it blew my mind. I like Neil Young, but I don't think there's really any competition for me.

[sifi]

Honestly, who needs drugs when you have PF??? The best band ever!!!

[The Nal]

Apart from the Final Cut. And the Wall. And Atom Heart Mother. And Ummagumma. And Obscured by Light. And Division Bell. And the Delicate Sound of Thunder. And Pulse.

Meddle, DSOTM, Animals, Four of the Five on WYWH and the first two Syd ones were class though.

[sifi]

Its Obscured by Clouds. Not Obscured by Light. I like it! Only in the nerdy way though. I wouldnt listen to it in the car.

The Wall is a classic man! Even if its a tough listen.

You forgot Momentary Lapse of Reason by the way. Total and utter shite.

Edited February 5, 2009 by sifimaster

[alframsey]

You are right about Obscured. It's not very good whatever it is. I understand it was important in their development.

The Wall has a few good tracks on it, but on the whole I find it too moany and self-indulgent for my liking. Didn't like the film either. Comfortably Numb and Run Like Hell are class mind.

I've not got More on there either, but then I've not heard it. I liked the cover of Momentary Lapse of Reason.

[strudders]

You are both wrong! Every PF album is good, very good infact!!! Apart from AMLOR, which can best be described as decent. The Wall is an all time classic, OBC is brilliant, AHM, Umagguma (never can spell that), TDB is brilliant. More is also brilliant!

Honestly, they have never done a treuly bad album, the best band ever!

[alframsey]

The Final cut was not Brilliant....... No RW, and a bit of a Waters monologue really.....

[strudders]

I really like The Final Cut, probs my 6/7 fave PF album. It is a brilliant album, but it depends whether you speakin musically or lyrically. Lyrically its fantastic, very strong, it tells a story no one else could. Musically it is lacking, a little. But it was never meant to be a musical album!

[alframsey]

only playing the devils aviate her so don't shoot me down... But was it really PF or was it RW with DG and NM as session musicians....

See I love Animals, number 2 in my book after number 1 of WYWH.

However some say that's a poor effort, I say rubbish..... I know, but I just felt it was the last good PF album before Rodger got all up tight.

Any this is so far off topic we are in another world......

[alframsey]

sooo..

who's better, Bruce or Neil?

Pink Floyd!!

how in the name of Bo Diddley did that happen

while we're here.. Obscured By Clouds is one of my favourite Floyd albums... good short songs... they don't do that very often

[sifi]

You are both wrong! Every PF album is good, very good infact!!! Apart from AMLOR, which can best be described as decent. The Wall is an all time classic, OBC is brilliant, AHM, Umagguma (never can spell that), TDB is brilliant. More is also brilliant!

Honestly, they have never done a treuly bad album, the best band ever!

Edited February 5, 2009 by sifimaster

[sdaveak47]

Hang on a moment whats all this !!!!

[When Jokers Attack]

Animals is criminally underated

[Radged Rich]

Neil Young hands down i'd rather have red hot nails pushed under my fingernails than suffer the other 1, he's poop & boring & predictable although i accept Mr Young is an aquired taste

[strudders]

Animals is criminally underated

[sdaveak47]

Well it looks like Bruce won afterall, due Neil being a bit of a greedy twat and not even turning up

[sifi]

Animals is criminally underated

[lilac]

Bruce is THE BOSS