Main Stage 1992 vs 2012

[RichieParf]

So in the same manner as the 2011 vs 2012 thread, a bit more fun 20 years since Nirvana, Grohl's back, but which would you rather see?

The Wonder Stuff vs The Cure

The Charlatans vs Paramore

Public Image Ltd. vs Bombat Bicycle Club

PJ Harvey vs You me at Six

Mega City Four vs Crystal Castles

Milltown Brothers vs Angels and Airwaves

The Fatima Mansions vs Coheed and Cambria

Redd Kross vs Cancer Bats

(Deaf Havana)

Public Enemy vs Kasabian

Ride vs Florence and the Machine

EMF vs The Vaccines

Manic Street Preachers vs Enter Shikari

The Farm vs The Shins

The Smashing Pumpkins vs OFWGKTA

Rollins Band vs Mystery Jets

Thousand Yard Stare vs Blood Red Shoes

(Buffalo Tom)

(Therapy?)

Nirvana vs Foo Fighters

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds vs The Black Keys

Mudhoney vs Kaiser Chiefs

Teenage Fanclub vs Bullet for my Valentine

L7 vs All Time Low

Beastie Boys vs The Gaslight Anthem

Björn Again vs Eagles of Death Metal

Pavement vs Band of Skulls

Screaming Trees vs Pulled Apart by Horses

(Melvins)

[Vieuphoria]

The Cure

The Charlatans

Public Image Ltd.

PJ Harvey

Crystal Castles

Milltown Brothers

Coheed and Cambria

Redd Kross

5 - 3

Public Enemy

Ride

EMF

Manic Street Preachers

The Shins

The Smashing Pumpkins

Rollins Band

Blood Red Shoes

Therapy?

6 - 2

Nirvana

The Black Keys

Mudhoney

Teenage Fanclub

L7

Beastie Boys

Eagles of Death Metal

Pavement

Screaming Trees

Melvins

7 - 2

[Martino231]

My favourite contrast here is The Smashing Pumpkins vs OFWGKTA.

[dirtymookie]

The Wonder Stuff vs The Cure

The Charlatans vs Paramore

Public Image Ltd. vs Bombat Bicycle Club

PJ Harvey vs You me at Six

Mega City Four vs Crystal Castles

Milltown Brothers vs Angels and Airwaves

The Fatima Mansions vs Coheed and Cambria

Redd Kross vs Cancer Bats

6-2

Public Enemy vs Kasabian

Ride vs Florence and the Machine

EMF vs The Vaccines

Manic Street Preachers vs Enter Shikari

The Farm vs The Shins

The Smashing Pumpkins vs OFWGKTA (the 92 version)

Rollins Band vs Mystery Jets

Buffalo Tom vs Blood Red Shoes

7-1

Nirvana vs Foo Fighters

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds vs The Black Keys

Mudhoney vs Kaiser Chiefs

Teenage Fanclub vs Bullet for my Valentine

L7 vs All Time Low

Beastie Boys vs The Gaslight Anthem

Björn Again vs Eagles of Death Metal

Pavement vs Band of Skulls

Screaming Trees vs Pulled Apart by Horses

(Melvins) would happily take the Melvins over almost any on this years line up too.

8-1

21-4 in total. Says it all really.

[2rare2die]

The Wonder Stuff vs The Cure

The Charlatans vs Paramore

Public Image Ltd. vs Bombat Bicycle Club

PJ Harvey vs You me at Six

Mega City Four vs Crystal Castles

Milltown Brothers vs Angels and Airwaves

The Fatima Mansions vs Coheed and Cambria

Redd Kross vs Cancer Bats

(Deaf Havana)

Public Enemy vs Kasabian

Ride vs Florence and the Machine

EMF vs The Vaccines

Manic Street Preachers vs Enter Shikari

The Farm vs The Shins

The Smashing Pumpkins vs OFWGKTA

Rollins Band vs Mystery Jets

Thousand Yard Stare vs Blood Red Shoes

(Buffalo Tom)

(Therapy?)

Nirvana vs Foo Fighters

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds vs The Black Keys

Mudhoney vs Kaiser Chiefs

Teenage Fanclub vs Bullet for my Valentine

L7 vs All Time Low

Beastie Boys vs The Gaslight Anthem

Björn Again vs Eagles of Death Metal

Pavement vs Band of Skulls

Screaming Trees vs Pulled Apart by Horses

Hmm 12 apiece

I think we should all do a comparison with the first year we attended and this year as well

[RichieParf]

My favourite contrast here is The Smashing Pumpkins vs OFWGKTA.

[kaosmark2]

The Wonder Stuff vs The Cure

The Charlatans vs Paramore

Public Image Ltd. vs Bombat Bicycle Club

PJ Harvey vs You me at Six

Mega City Four vs Crystal Castles

Milltown Brothers vs Angels and Airwaves

The Fatima Mansions vs Coheed and Cambria

Redd Kross vs Cancer Bats

(Deaf Havana)

Public Enemy vs Kasabian

Ride vs Florence and the Machine

EMF vs The Vaccines

Manic Street Preachers vs Enter Shikari

The Farm vs The Shins

The Smashing Pumpkins vs OFWGKTA

Rollins Band vs Mystery Jets

Thousand Yard Stare vs Blood Red Shoes

(Buffalo Tom)

(Therapy?)

Nirvana vs Foo Fighters

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds vs The Black Keys

Mudhoney vs Kaiser Chiefs

Teenage Fanclub vs Bullet for my Valentine

L7 vs All Time Low

Beastie Boys vs The Gaslight Anthem

Björn Again vs Eagles of Death Metal

Pavement vs Band of Skulls

Screaming Trees vs Pulled Apart by Horses

(Melvins)

14 vs 5

That Sunday mainstage was incredible.

[The Mean Bean]

The Wonder Stuff vs The Cure

The Charlatans vs Paramore

Public Image Ltd. vs Bombat Bicycle Club

PJ Harvey vs You me at Six

Mega City Four vs Crystal Castles

Milltown Brothers vs Angels and Airwaves (don't know anything about Milltown Bros, hate AVA)

The Fatima Mansions vs Coheed and Cambria

Redd Kross vs Cancer Bats

(Deaf Havana)

Public Enemy vs Kasabian

Ride vs Florence and the Machine

EMF vs The Vaccines

Manic Street Preachers vs Enter Shikari

The Farm vs The Shins

The Smashing Pumpkins vs OFWGKTA

Rollins Band vs Mystery Jets

Thousand Yard Stare vs Blood Red Shoes

(Buffalo Tom)

(Therapy?)

Nirvana vs Foo Fighters

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds vs The Black Keys

Mudhoney vs Kaiser Chiefs

Teenage Fanclub vs Bullet for my Valentine

L7 vs All Time Low

Beastie Boys vs The Gaslight Anthem

Björn Again vs Eagles of Death Metal

Pavement vs Band of Skulls

Screaming Trees vs Pulled Apart by Horses

(Melvins)

If any festival today had Nirvana, The Smashing Pumpkins, Pavement and Manic Street Preachers, you'd have a hard time keeping me away from it.

[VCK]

Manic Street Preachers vs Enter Shikari

The Smashing Pumpkins vs OFWGKTA

[Dead throne]

Nirvana vs Foo Fighters

[let's 'ave it!!!]

Remember, those 1992 bands weren't all as big as they are now. It's always easy to look back on a line-up thinking it was better than it really was

[dirtymookie]

...

[dirtymookie]

Remember, those 1992 bands weren't all as big as they are now. It's always easy to look back on a line-up thinking it was better than it really was

[Lithium05]

Can't believe how many people are going for Black Keys over Nick Cave. Shame on the lot of you!

[Vieuphoria]

I was stuck with that one. But figure Black Keys would be better live. Not sure why

[kaosmark2]

I was stuck with that one. But figure Black Keys would be better live. Not sure why

[Vieuphoria]

Ah fair enough. I've seen videos of Grinderman that look fantastic. I'd like to see Nick Cave actually

[kaosmark2]

Ah fair enough. I've seen videos of Grinderman that look fantastic. I'd like to see Nick Cave actually

[Dead throne]

Are you saying thats a hard choice?

[dirtymookie]

Not nessesarely....

Nirvana are overrated and foo fighters too mainstream. Just my opinion, but ya...

[charley]

I think we should all do a comparison with the first year we attended and this year as well

[alex28]

The Wonder Stuff vs The Cure

The Charlatans vs Paramore

Public Image Ltd. vs Bombat Bicycle Club

PJ Harvey vs You me at Six

Mega City Four vs Crystal Castles

Milltown Brothers vs Angels and Airwaves

The Fatima Mansions vs Coheed and Cambria

Redd Kross vs Cancer Bats

(Deaf Havana)

Public Enemy vs Kasabian

Ride vs Florence and the Machine

EMF vs The Vaccines

Manic Street Preachers vs Enter Shikari

The Farm vs The Shins

The Smashing Pumpkins vs OFWGKTA

Rollins Band vs Mystery Jets

Thousand Yard Stare vs Blood Red Shoes

(Buffalo Tom)

(Therapy?)

Nirvana vs Foo Fighters

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds vs The Black Keys

Mudhoney vs Kaiser Chiefs

Teenage Fanclub vs Bullet for my Valentine

L7 vs All Time Low

Beastie Boys vs The Gaslight Anthem

Björn Again vs Eagles of Death Metal

Pavement vs Band of Skulls

Screaming Trees vs Pulled Apart by Horses

(Melvins)

[dirtymookie]

The Wonder Stuff vs The Cure

The Charlatans vs Paramore

Public Image Ltd. vs Bombat Bicycle Club

PJ Harvey vs You me at Six

Mega City Four vs Crystal Castles

Milltown Brothers vs Angels and Airwaves (don't know anything about Milltown Bros, hate AVA)

The Fatima Mansions vs Coheed and Cambria

Redd Kross vs Cancer Bats

(Deaf Havana)

Public Enemy vs Kasabian

Ride vs Florence and the Machine

EMF vs The Vaccines

Manic Street Preachers vs Enter Shikari

The Farm vs The Shins

The Smashing Pumpkins vs OFWGKTA

Rollins Band vs Mystery Jets

Thousand Yard Stare vs Blood Red Shoes

(Buffalo Tom)

(Therapy?)

Nirvana vs Foo Fighters

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds vs The Black Keys

Mudhoney vs Kaiser Chiefs

Teenage Fanclub vs Bullet for my Valentine

L7 vs All Time Low

Beastie Boys vs The Gaslight Anthem

Björn Again vs Eagles of Death Metal

Pavement vs Band of Skulls

Screaming Trees vs Pulled Apart by Horses

(Melvins)

If any festival today had Nirvana, The Smashing Pumpkins, Pavement and Manic Street Preachers, you'd have a hard time keeping me away from it.