Rate The Debut Albums Of Your Ten Favourite Bands

[kaosmark2]

Ahhh yes. Green Day/Skrillex and Eminem/Alt-J was a difficult choice for many to make on here last year

[Gucci Piggy]

Out of those choices I picked:

Go to my parents and have a bath.

Be on shift.

[Gucci Piggy]

And I could have had a nice night of Deftones > SOAD > CHVRCHES > Crystal Fighters on the Green Day night if some plebs hadn't told me how good Green Day are live. HEYYYYYY OHHHHHH.

[dancelittleliar]

Nick Drake 9/10

Bowie 3/10

Talking Heads 7.5/10

Radiohead 4/10 (Amnesiac > In Rainbows > Kid A > Ok Computer > King of Limbs > Hail to the Thief > The Bends > Pablo Honey)

My Bloody Valentine 7/10

Kanye West 9/10

The xx 7.5/10

Portishead 9/10

Fuck Buttons 8.5/10

Daft Punk 8/10

[Com Truise]

Foals > Tame Impala > Pizza > Tomahawk > Savages > British Sea Power was a tasty run on the Eminem night to be fair

[TheSilence]

Foals were soooo dull. Worst I saw all weekend

[Gucci Piggy]

Foals seemed like the least dull band of all time following White Lies.

[Yellow_Fellow]

foals killed my hopes and dreams

[Gucci Piggy]

Let Down would be a 10/10 album by itself

[justanothername]

Foals weren't that bad compared to We Are The In Crowd

[Tobieski]

Foals weren't that bad compared to We Are The In Crowd

[Ipayne]

Biffy Clyro - Blackened Sky - 9/10 (3rd out of 6)

The White Stripes - S/T - 8/10 (3rd out of 6)

RHCP - RHCP - 2/10 (10th out of 10)

Black Sabbath - S/T - 9/10 (4th out of 19)

Jane's Addiction - Nothing's Shocking - 10/10 (1st out of 4)

Alice In Chains - Facelift - 7/10 (2nd out of 5)

Muse - Showbiz - 9/10 (3rd out of 6)

Soundgarden - Ultra Mega OK - 5/10 (6th out of 6)

Pearl Jam - Ten - 10/10 (2nd out of 10)

Led Zeppelin - S/T - 10/10 (1st out of 9)

[Babyquack]

Go to my parents and have a bath.

[The Placid Casual]

More that could easily enter my top 10 (NMH probably are now after their show):

Neutral Milk Hotel - On Avery Island - 8/10 2nd best behind In The Aeroplane Over The Sea

Manic Street Preachers - Generation Terrorists - 8/10 2nd best behind The Holy Bible

Massive Attack - Blue Lines - 9/10 2nd best behind Mezzanine

The Streets - Original Pirate Material - 10/10 Their best album

Blur - Leisure - 6/10 Their worst album

Vampire Weekend - Vampire Weekend - 9/10 Their best album

Biffy Clyro - Blackened Sky - 8/10 Their 5th best album

[kaosmark2]

Portishead 9/10

[Gucci Piggy]

You missed Dookie?! I couldn't have cared less about the rest of the set as it was disappointing but was still nice to hear Dookie in full

Wtf?! White Lies were incredible last year. One of my favourite live bands (I'm pretty sure they're the band I've seen the most )

[dancelittleliar]

You think albums can get better than Dummy?/quote]

I always feel uncomfortable giving anything a 10. 10 means literally cannot ever be beaten. How do I know I won't like something else better? Can't believe I forgot them but Doors' debut would get 9.5

[Gucci Piggy]

Thinking about this a bit more, I'd probably give Funeral a 10, but I dunno if I'd class Arcade Fire in my 10 favourite bands. Probably not. Not really that many albums I'd give 10 to:

Origin of Symmetry

OK Computer

Kid A

In Raibows

In the Aeroplane Over the Sea

Mezzanine

The Downward Spiral

LZ IV

Disintegration

Wish

Ten

Different Class

Loveless

Funeral

Probably a few more I've forgotten. I know I said I'd only class one Radiohead album as a 10 but thinking about it I'd probably give 10's to all three of those.

Edited May 22, 2014 by Will-2609

[mattgimmeshelter]

2012 was pretty swell too... Even though I only went on the foos day

That was a good day

[mattgimmeshelter]

Matt42 actually likes Meat Loaf haha, told me.

[Gucci Piggy]

My dad likes meatloaf. So 50% of me likes meatloaf

Work out that percentage if I'm 80% of you

[mattgimmeshelter]

My dad has the strangest taste in music, now I've thought of it.

Favourite bands, led zeppelin, genesis, anything by Peter Gabriel.... And then meatloaf and kate bush.

[dentalplan]

How does he rate their debuts?

[The Placid Casual]

Seems Will did it, here's my 10/10s that I can think of right now

Origin of Symmetry

OK Computer

In Rainbows

Kid A (Yeah, my mind's changed that quickly)

Original Pirate Material

Unknown Pleasures

Closer

In the Aeroplane Over the Sea

Revolver

The Holy Bible

Up the Bracket

Funeral

FIDLAR

Pinkerton

The Queen is Dead

Music Has the Right to Children

Mezzanine

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy

The Stone Roses

Led Zeppelin IV

[Yellow_Fellow]

10 means literally cannot ever be beaten.