Would you swap Arcade Fire for Muse

[wacko]

Ok so although not fully confirmed it looks like Reading and Leeds have Arcade Fire headlining while as we all know by now Muse will headline Glasto.

So inspired by another topic I just wondered how many people would swap headliners given the choice?

This question is also in the glastonbury forum so go over there to check out what them lot think.

(just to be clear, its never going to happen, just curious as to what people going to each festival think)

Edited March 10, 2010 by wacko

[Role Model]

hell no

[neatneatneat]

Ok so although not fully confirmed it looks like Reading and Leeds have Arcade Fire headlining while as we all know by now Muse will headline Glasto.

So inspired by another topic I just wondered how many people would swap headliners given the choice?

This question is also in the glastonbury forum so go over there to check out what them lot think.

[Electricityscape]

I want Arcade Fire there, but not headlining. And anyway Muse over them anyway.

[Vieuphoria]

I'd swap Muse for MCR or Blink any day. But not for AF.

[likelyladtom]

No, but only because I've seen Muse twice already.

[kev1664]

No because I'm going to see Muse the weekend after Leeds, and for that reason I don't want to see muse at the festival.

Any other year id have said yes swap them. But the main reason they arnt playing r and l is cos they have there own shows. Be it benefitial for FR or Muse themselves.

[Lithium05]

No, I don't like either. But at least with AF you don't get all this crap Muse fans spout about them being the best live act in the world - I've seen them, they're really not.

[Role Model]

No, I don't like either. But at least with AF you don't get all this crap Muse fans spout about them being the best live act in the world - I've seen them, they're really not.

[olly!olly!olly!]

yes.

Only because i'm definately going to glasto and only probably going to leeds.

AF are better

[paulos316]

I wouldnt swap Arcade fire for any band in the world at the minute.... Can't w8 to see em live !!!!

[rexclark]

Arcade Fire every time.

[John92]

Muse - I want to see what all the hype is about...

[Museaholic]

The best live band in the world versus some boring indie band that are no way big enough to headline, hell yes, but they won't be playing this year.

[John92]

No, I don't like either. But at least with AF you don't get all this crap Muse fans spout about them being the best live act in the world - I've seen them, they're really not.

[gr4h4m]

who the f**k are Arcade Fire? why are they headlining and what have they done since they last played?

This whole thing just seems desperate, they seem to have failed big time so are just booking bands which simply ain't big enough to headline

[Museaholic]

Lol

[John92]

Fine if you don't like them, your loss, but there certainly better than AF.

[Museaholic]

I like Muse, theyre not my favourite band, but I do like them... I was just laughing at the irony

[biglewhill]

who the f**k are Arcade Fire? why are they headlining and what have they done since they last played?

This whole thing just seems desperate, they seem to have failed big time so are just booking bands which simply ain't big enough to headline

[Joshuwarr]

Muse aren't good enough live to warrant my vote I'm afraid. A beautiful musical ensemble >>> Pyrotechnics and Bellamy's piano w*nkery.

[thomasowen]

Close call. I prefer Arcade Fire on record, and they are amazing live but I wouldn't say they are ready to headline yet. Muse on the otherhand are a bit old hat and their last album wasn't very good. That said they know how to fill one and a half hours and they would sure sell tickets. I would have to go with them.

[Englishdragon]

If Muse were one of the 3 - Id seriously consider buying a ticket.

Arcade Fire, Blink, MCR - Not even putting any money aside.

[cheeseisamazing]

Just looked at the Glasot one. I love the way the majority at reading want muse and majority at glasto want arcade.

personally Muse> Arcade fire.

but then thats me

[SpiralD]

I've seen Muse twice, once on The Resistance tour, and I've never seen Arcade Fire live.... Tough call.

I went with Muse anyway.