Idles

[Sasperella]

9 hours ago, priest17 said:

No one does a pompous put down review quite as well as The Quietus, they should be saved at all costs.

"Idles' hearts are in the right place but so was Tony Benn's and his last album was shit."

still looking forward to the album but enjoyed this read: https://thequietus.com/articles/28899-idles-ultra-mono-review?fbclid=IwAR2AMm2F8-FKSebZE0Ynl4UPfDVan3csuWDO2YbvsMKes9FbWzwwcgPhLL8

I obviously hate this. Even if it is funny. 

[vintagelaureate]

On 9/10/2020 at 11:55 AM, priest17 said:

No one does a pompous put down review quite as well as The Quietus, they should be saved at all costs.

"Idles' hearts are in the right place but so was Tony Benn's and his last album was shit."

still looking forward to the album but enjoyed this read: https://thequietus.com/articles/28899-idles-ultra-mono-review?fbclid=IwAR2AMm2F8-FKSebZE0Ynl4UPfDVan3csuWDO2YbvsMKes9FbWzwwcgPhLL8

I do like IDLES response to this: 

For a bit of info:

 

[vintagelaureate]

[dentalplan]

1 hour ago, vintagelaureate said:

I do like IDLES response to this: 

For a bit of info:

 

Surprised they only released it in one colour.

[zahidf]

Oops

 

[FloorFiller]

These guys need to lay off of the interview circuit - it’s doing nothing but harm to their image.

Did find this very funny though 

 

[priest17]

8 minutes ago, FloorFiller said:

These guys need to lay off of the interview circuit - it’s doing nothing but harm to their image.

Did find this very funny though 

 

I hope they start getting mean and the 4th albums called "just fuck off yeah?"

[dentalplan]

Jesus. What a disastrous interview to kick off the press campaign. They seem to care more than anyone in the world about what Sleaford Mods think.

This album is starting out on the wrong foot completely so I hope the songs we haven’t heard really turn things around.

[nikkic]

Are IDLES becoming everything they hate? 

[dentalplan]

Maybe it’s just a struggle to deal with being one of Britain’s biggest bands and the attention it draws to them from the likes of NME, The Quietus, other artists. Hopefully they just get over it, get their heads down and kick out some jams.

[Winslow Leach]

I’m sorry you had to find out this way but they are, and always have been, the BrewDog of punk.

[zahidf]

They replied to nadine tbf to them

 

 

[Winslow Leach]

Fair play to Idles though, it took Frank Turner a lot longer than this to burn through all his good will 

[kingcrawler]

I think there was always going to be a backlash at some point, it happens to most bands once they become really big but particularly so for Idles given the kind of band they are. They seemed to have near universal acclaim for the last couple of years but I feel like things have definitely turned a bit this year. People are always going to criticise a big band who have spent the last two years being very present and opinionated and it seems like they're struggling to deal with that. 

I'm not sure if it's because the new songs seem much more divisive than previously (though given how many tickets their tour sold maybe this isn't relevant) but between that and the criticism they come across really insecure in any recent interview I've read. I agree with others that taking a break from PR for a bit might do them good. It seems like the harder they try, the worse it gets. 

[Mouseboy11]

The AF Gang page will make for good reading

[JSmurphy]

Worst Idles content since Model Village.

[JSmurphy]

Genuinely cannot be arsed with the vitriol and toxicity of the discourse on this mind. Not on here - the usual places. 

 

[Chawk]

i don't think anything they said was that bad. seems like people just being keen to shoot them down

[Quark]

Thing is, as soon as anyone sticks their head above the parapet the expectation is then there for them to be A1 perfect on every aspect, otherwise they're hypocrites.

Protesting for a fairer global economic system? Fuck off, you once bought a Starbucks. 

Demanding coordinated global action to address climate change? You flew to a conference once, go fuck yourself. 

Etc etc etc...

Edited September 18, 2020 by Quark

[FloorFiller]

16 minutes ago, Chawk said:

i don't think anything they said was that bad. seems like people just being keen to shoot them down

Yeah they’ve just become the new whipping boys because what used to be endearing and funny about their schtick has now grown tired and corny, and their constant being on the defence about their detractors doesn’t help. Hopefully come album time this will all be forgotten, although I’m definitely gonna be going in to it with lowered expectations (due to the pre-release stuff - I don’t really care if they occasionally come off as cringey knobheads).

[Hugh Jass]

2 hours ago, FloorFiller said:

These guys need to lay off of the interview circuit - it’s doing nothing but harm to their image.

Did find this very funny though 

 

I’m looking forward to hearing their next single on a DFS advert.

[Gilgamesh69]

Saw an AFganger the other day, saying he saw Prodigy in the 90s but he reckons Idles next year is gonna be even better.

 

Like come on, they're really not THAT good

[Jay Pee]

The NME interview ain't that bad is it? 

The sofa advertising metadata is lolz.  

At least it wasn't adverts for Vera Lynn tea towels or Daily Mail Royalist porn calendars

[Ryan1984]

Not sure if Nadine’s response to their reply is sarky or sincere?

 

[FloorFiller]

48 minutes ago, Ryan1984 said:

Not sure if Nadine’s response to their reply is sarky or sincere?

 

Sounds pretty damn sarcastic, doesn’t it? 😄